Columbus Crew stunned Lionel Messi and Inter Miami 3-0 in Game 1 of their MLS Cup Playoffs first-round series on Saturday, with Gonzalo Tapia scoring twice and the defending champions reduced to 10 men before half-time.
The seventh-seeded Crew, the 2023 champions, delivered the first upset of the Audi 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs at Miami’s Nu Stadium, beating the No. 2 seed in front of a shellshocked home crowd. Columbus can now eliminate Messi and the reigning champions with a victory in Game 2 in Ohio on Friday.
Tapia Strikes Early, Then Again
Gonzalo Tapia opened the scoring from the penalty spot in the ninth minute, and the Chile international was the central figure all night. Already a goal up, Columbus took complete control in the 36th minute when Miami defender Gonzalo Luján was sent off, leaving the hosts down to 10 men.
Taha Habroune, the Crew’s homegrown midfielder, padded the lead in the 52nd minute, finishing from Brais Méndez’s assist. Six minutes later Tapia struck for a brace, this time from Steven Moreira’s pass, and the result was settled at 3-0.
Columbus goalkeeper Patrick Schulte made five saves to keep Miami out, including a diving stop to deny Messi from a trademark free-kick. Miami had chances, with Messi, Germán Berterame and Telasco Segovia all testing Schulte, but the Crew goalkeeper was equal to everything.
Messi’s Frustrating Night
It was a miserable evening for Messi, and it started with a celebration. Before kick-off, Inter Miami co-owner Jorge Mas presented the Argentine with the 2026 Golden Boot award, which he had won earlier in the month. From there, little went right.
Messi was shown a yellow card at half-time after bouncing the ball off the side of Tapia’s face as frustrations boiled over, and he was fortunate to escape dismissal for the incident. Fans booed as the players walked off the field at the break, with Miami already a goal down and a man short.
In the second half, Messi looked dangerous but not decisive. He took two shots on target, forced Schulte into good saves and completed four dribbles, but he also lost possession 17 times as Columbus contained him. The Crew’s game plan was clear: frustrate Messi, stay compact, and punish Miami on the break. It worked perfectly.
Luján Sees Red
The turning point came in the 36th minute. Luján, who had already been booked in the 13th minute, was sent off for a second yellow, and Miami’s task went from difficult to near-impossible. Down to 10 men and a goal behind, the hosts could not find a way back into the game, and Columbus scored twice more after the break.
Miami will also be without Luján for Game 2, after his red card earned him a suspension. That is a significant blow for a side that must now win in Columbus simply to keep their title defence alive.
What the Result Means
The series is a best-of-three, with the first team to win two games advancing to the Conference Semifinals. Columbus lead 1-0, and a win in Game 2 on Friday, November 27, at ScottsMiracle-Gro Field in Columbus would end Miami’s season and Messi’s bid for back-to-back MLS Cup titles.
If Miami win Game 2, the series returns to Miami for a decisive Game 3 on December 2. But the champions will have to do it without Luján, and they will have to find a way past a Columbus side that has now beaten them twice in a row, including a 2-1 win in their most recent regular-season meeting on September 27.
For Columbus, this was a statement. The seventh seed went into the home of the champions, scored three goals, kept a clean sheet, and silenced Messi. One more win, and the Crew are through to the Conference Semifinals.